![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
learnedaxForgot, I also saw another movie yesterday.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
tpau, dkapell, knobhdy, and I saw The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. It was a McMovie, part of the growing trend of churning out homogeneous ensemble action films nominally adapted from something else. X-men the first, Ocean's Eleven, and The Italian Job (which I saw on Wednesday and thought was quite enjoyable) are other examples of this problem. Even LOTR has clearly been straining against hollywoodism. I thought that LXG was a particularly egregious case in that they mangled such an erudite source. Why not have Justice League: The Film if you are going to be vapid about it? The original comic is subtle and victorian, where the film could be modern day, with modern characters for all the style they impart. I disrecommend it. Even more strongly, if you are ever interested in reading the comic, don't see the movie. Some have said they would rather see the movie first so that they aren't disappointed by it, but this film is not worth such sacrifice. The comic is in large part a puzzle, with many persons' identities kept mysterious for a long time. If you see the movie that will be ruined for you.
As a side note, I've noticed that modern movies have shockingly bad fight scenes. They tend toward choppy, close-up, and incoherent. It's frequently very hard to tell who's killing whom. LXG is certainly a good example of this, but by far not the worst. My suspicion is that Gladiator, which as you may recall was praised for its "fantastic" action sequences, may have been a major influence in this area. Seeing Pirates of the Caribbean drove home that it is indeed possible to make complex but interesting film combat.
tpau, dkapell, knobhdy, and I saw The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. It was a McMovie, part of the growing trend of churning out homogeneous ensemble action films nominally adapted from something else. X-men the first, Ocean's Eleven, and The Italian Job (which I saw on Wednesday and thought was quite enjoyable) are other examples of this problem. Even LOTR has clearly been straining against hollywoodism. I thought that LXG was a particularly egregious case in that they mangled such an erudite source. Why not have Justice League: The Film if you are going to be vapid about it? The original comic is subtle and victorian, where the film could be modern day, with modern characters for all the style they impart. I disrecommend it. Even more strongly, if you are ever interested in reading the comic, don't see the movie. Some have said they would rather see the movie first so that they aren't disappointed by it, but this film is not worth such sacrifice. The comic is in large part a puzzle, with many persons' identities kept mysterious for a long time. If you see the movie that will be ruined for you.As a side note, I've noticed that modern movies have shockingly bad fight scenes. They tend toward choppy, close-up, and incoherent. It's frequently very hard to tell who's killing whom. LXG is certainly a good example of this, but by far not the worst. My suspicion is that Gladiator, which as you may recall was praised for its "fantastic" action sequences, may have been a major influence in this area. Seeing Pirates of the Caribbean drove home that it is indeed possible to make complex but interesting film combat.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2003-07-14 09:36 am (UTC)Always a bad sign when they refer to the actor and not the character. I mean, was it Harrison Ford and the Temple of Doom? Was it James Earl Jones Strikes Back? Was it Sigourney Weaver's Aliens Die Die Die!? Was it Elijah Wood and the Rather Plain But Portentious Trinket (with Viggo Mortenson)?!?! (Deep breathses...deep breatheses, my precious.) Okay, I'm better now.
Now, if Sean Connery were suddenly transported back to Victorian England and had to solve a crisis based on his knowledge of twentieth-century action films he's starred in and decided to gather up noteworthy historical authors drowning their worries in local pubs and then mix those with the fantastic ideas those authors had for their fictional creations--maybe intercut with scenes illustrating their novels--that might be a movie.
Shockingly bad fight scenes: Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle. 'Nuff said.
no subject
Date: 2003-07-14 10:02 am (UTC)TMH